• Home
  • Buy
  • Author
  • Press
  • Video
  • Blog
  • Links
  • Cover Images
Eric is Awake

The Anonymous Citizen

Notes from a fleshy tube of chemicals in UK Inc.

Go Buy an Eric

Where to Stand in the Fourth Estate

8/22/2013

0 Comments

 
PictureJuvenal
The torrid debates around the detention of David Miranda, partner of Guardian journalist Glenn Greenwald and the actions taken against journalists in the phone hacking scandal have exposed a potential set of double standards that has red-top tabloid champions seething at the perceived injustice and the UK’s Guardian newspaper claiming the higher ground. The tone is unmistakable as both sides take the mastiffs of their prejudices out for a little walk around the Fourth Estate.

In one corner, Brendan O’Neill and many others deride the Guardian’s railing at the use of Terrorism legislation against what it defines as legitimate journalistic endeavour, whilst staying silent on the long judicial limbo hovering over their compatriots in the hacking scandal.

 In the other, the broadsheets point to the moral chasm between investigative journalism that holds the Government to account and prurient muckraking amongst celebrities and the families of murder victims. In the digital din of perpetual content churn, it is not always Juvenal’s question ‘who shall guard the guardians?’ that is being answered.

Leaving aside the increasingly frequent instances when these two worlds collide and a broadsheet behaves like a tabloid and vice versa, the arguments on both sides have some legitimacy regardless of the context. Where you stand on Fleet Street should not determine how strongly you defend the principle of public interest over public prurience.

The use of legitimate investigative methods and being allowed to make a public interest case for the use of leaked whistleblower material that speaks truth to power should be a constant. The press should always be testing this principle and it is a tension that must exist if their role is to have any significance in the age of Yochai Benkler’s Networked Fourth Estate defined as ‘the set of practices, organizing models, and technologies that are associated with the free press and provide a public check on the branches of government.’ For some reason he doesn’t mention the upskirt shots of the paparazzi and the practice of ‘collects’ - those intimate photos of the murder victim, coaxed from grieving families usually by the unpaid interns now ubiquitous at both ends of Grub Street, but then he’s a busy man.

When politicians prohibited from conflating their personal financial interests with their public position are then found to be taking the shilling of those they award access to patronage, it is legitimate for that hypocrisy to be exposed and the argument can then be had about the methods used to discover this information. It’s just a shame it happens every news day. Repetition dulls the readership however proud curmudgeonly ancient Roman finger waggers such as Juvenal would be.

However if a soap star or local mayor has not suggested fidelity as the abiding tenet of their every waking breath, then the details of their fornication with the lower mammals or the surprising use of random items from the fruit bowl to satisfy their baser desires is interesting and may sell papers and groceries, but is none of our business. Entertaining though, isn’t it? But if the aim is to feed the entertainment industry, then that is not and never has been journalism. That is treating Juvenal to an  up-toga shot. That’ll teach him to step out of his chariot without his knees locked together.

Both stories may have been exposed by similar means, but it’s the principle not the methods that need defending. Everything else is PR.



0 Comments

    AuthorBot

    Dom Shaw is the author of 'Eric is Awake' and also a fleshy tube of chemicals working as a writer, scriptwriter and filmmaker in the UK. Was a boy, now a man. He lives.  

    Archives

    January 2024
    May 2020
    March 2019
    August 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013

    Categories

    All
    All The Years Of Trying
    Ana Mendieta Carl Andre Cliched Conversations Tate Gallery Quentin Crisp Modern Art Rome Stephen Geller
    Anti-apartheid Chris De Broglio Portman Court Hotel Breyten Breytenbach South Africa Sport Peter Hain Arthur Ashe Muhammad Ali
    Bradley Manning Hacktivists Ancient Rome Standing On Your Head Monetise
    Cabal
    Celebrities St James's Park Angelina Jolie Brad Pitt Heron Pelicans Russell Crowe Squirrels Entertainment Industry Paparazzi
    Chemical Weapons Convention Syria Obama John Kerry Putin Bismarck Realpolitik Germany Prussia Gas Russia Us
    CIA
    Comey
    Coronavirus
    Deep State
    Depression
    Drugs Legalisation Herion Nhs Mike Barton Durham Police Chief Transform Drug Policy Foundation
    FBI
    General Alexander James Clapper Nsa Gchq Mi5 Samuel Johnson Patriotism Gchq Math Orwellian Arithmetic Patriot Act Usa Uk Special Relationship
    George Orwell Isle Of Jura Barnhill 1984 Eric Blair Awake
    Harold Wilson
    Insurrection
    Iran Nowruz Huac Zero Mostel Mi5 Gchq
    Juvenal Fourth Estate David Miranda Glenn Greenwald Yochai Benkler Brendan O'neill Guardian Newspaper Hacking Scandal Leveson Fleet Street
    Lockdown
    MI5
    Miranda Censorship Journalism Snowden Milton Areopagitica Orwell Prention Of Literature Soviet Putin Bulgakov
    Mitt Romney Bain Capital Seamus Dog
    Nelson Mandela ANC Ruth First Church Street Bombing Ghandi Non-violence Umkhonto We Sizwe
    Nsa Mi5 Snowden Bletchley Park Surveillance Roman Empire Pax Romana
    Olympics Queen Sun City Mandela Apartheid Sports Boycott Stephen Fry Sebastian Coe Joe Ebrahim South Africa Dennis Brutus Tommie Smith John Carlos
    Orwell 1984 Brighton Writers Group Novel Us Tv
    Orwell 1984 Surveillance Nsa
    Panasonic AJ-HPX3700 Gorilla David Attenborough Wildlife Cameraman
    Patrik Fitzgerald Punk Poet Bob Geldof Boomtown Rats Roundhouse London Benjamin Zephaniah Everett True Rough Cut And Ready Dubbed
    Peter Wright
    Porlock Samuel Taylor Coleridge Inspiration Ideas Writers
    Public Sector Nhs Privatise Bbc John Birt Corpritization
    Red Things Rough Cut And Ready Dubbed Art Of The Critic Eric Is Awake Richard Dreyfus Close Encounters
    Retrospective Diagnosis Mentally Ill Lithium Orwell Christopher Hitchens Aspergers Fox Network Socialist
    Russell Brand Revolution Voting Is Dead Democracy Chartists Orwell Yeats Awake
    Russian Revolution Harry Young Lenin Comintern Bukharin Zinoviev Young Communist League Uk Cockney Commissar
    Scriptwriting
    Sedition
    Snowden Privacy Electronic Frontier Foundation Tor Network Reset The Net Julius Caesar Cryptography Encryption Mi5 Nsa Gchq Hello Kitty Google Metadata Intrusion
    Thoreau Walden Living Off The Grid Society Drop Out Self-sufficiency Nuisance Abatement Survivalists Living Off The Land
    Tony Blair David Cameron Syria War History Falklands Bosnia
    Tracey Emin Ivan Massow Conceptual Art Ica Critics Comedy Film
    Trump
    Writing

    RSS Feed