• Home
  • Buy
  • Author
  • Press
  • Video
  • Blog
  • Links
  • Cover Images
Eric is Awake

The Anonymous Citizen

Notes from a fleshy tube of chemicals in UK Inc.

Go Buy an Eric

Is everyone mentally ill?

7/21/2013

0 Comments

 
Picture
The art of retrospective diagnosis has never been more prevalent amongst the literary/psychology axis powers that blog themselves a few inches in the press by confidently applying their theories to characters such as Einstein and George Orwell. Christopher Hitchens suggested George Orwell’s difficulty in social situations might be a symptom of Aspergers Syndrome, whilst Tony Percy suggested any psychologically based analysis showed that his flawed analysis, lack of patience with abstract thought and his romanticised view of socialism all confirm this diagnosis. Percy even rues the ‘fact’ that Asperger’s Syndrome prevented him from being a more useful social critic, which belies the wealth of social criticism Orwell accurately analysed in his diaries and his many essays. This also ignores Orwell’s capacity for self analysis. Of his wartime diaries the writer observed that whenever it was possible to be wrong, he had been wrong. Both Right and Left are able to claim him because he could, as biographer Gordon Bowker observed, ‘hold two opposing views simultaneously’. If changing your mind when the evidence you relied upon is shown to be unreliable is a telling characteristic of a mental disorder, then this suggests the unchanging ideologues of Right and Left such as those amongst the Socialist Worker’s Party and the Fox network, who reject any evidence that does not conform to their world view, are perfectly sane. And that’s just mad.

Whilst there are some aspects to Orwell’s character that may lend themselves to any number of mental disorders, (those obsessive compulsive lists and calculations in his domestic diaries that leaked into some of his essays) the more pertinent question is not whether Orwell and several other historical figures whose names are always dropped in these analyses, (Churchill, Hitler, Newton et al) are mentally ill but whether the human condition puts us all ‘on the spectrum’ of madness to one degree or another.  

Obsessive Compulsive Disorder is seen as a person attempting to control their environment and ultimately their fate. When we are children and most of our environment feels completely out of our influence and affected by the large slow moving adults around us, we often display what psychologists might term typical OCD behaviours. ‘If I touch every single fencepost on the way home, Mummy will not discover the broken teapot I hid under the dresser and if I correctly guess kippers for tea, Daddy will not be killed by the Germans for I am the ruler of the universe and am in ultimate control of my fate’. As we grow up, these insecurities are subsumed by a growing confidence or suppressed to a degree that is manageable or, in the minority of cases, retained to be diagnosed by a man in a more expensive suit  than we could ever afford for $140 an hour plus tax.

Orwell’s paranoia is also cited as another indicator. But how many of us can put themselves in the position of a writer who had already appeared on one death list during the Spanish Civil War and who believed by retreating to the remote Isle of Jura he might escape the worst effects of a third Atom Bomb explosion? Given the time in which he lived and his previous experiences, one might think it a healthy precaution to be ever so slightly paranoid about over-friendly strangers and high profile social situations.

The truth is, we may regard our response to the world, our environment and our immediate personal experiences as being ‘on a spectrum’ of response and behaviours that are shaped by formative episodes in our childhood or genetics or physical injury to the brain. These responses are over-characterised for conveniences sake by professionals who desire a scale against which these things can be weighed, measured and treated. I have never experienced an age where there has been such a desire to label people as suffering from Bipolar Affective Disorder. The reason? Because, helpfully, a list of heavily promoted drugs are listed against such a diagnosis and prevent your GP or mental health professional from having to think very deeply about the appropriate treatment for how you feel when in a temporary or intermittent period of intense stress, anxiety or depression. Far easier to see the recommended Pharmacopoeia choices available for such a diagnosis and prescribe them.  

That is not to say that human beings with high levels of manic anxiety or depression do not genuinely benefit from a period (perhaps a long period) of medication to control the life-altering levels of pain and suffering caused by real and demonstrably disabling conditions. No one who has seen the distressing effects of delusional psychosis on the sufferer and their families would deny they need some chemical intervention to relieve their pain and stabilise their racing minds. But we have to be careful in a world dominated by Big Pharma not to become blind to the degrees along that human spectrum and allow a default position that can pathologise every aspect of human behaviour.

Reading and re-reading Orwell with a degree of intensity that may seem, dare I say, Obsessively Compulsive, I would conclude that during his time in Barcelona, on a death list and on the run from Fascist and Republican alike, I would have prescribed Lithium to bring down his manic tendency to believe that everyone is out to kill him with a side order of Zopiclone to help him with those sleepless nights. War is Peace. Freedom is Slavery. Ignorance is Strength. Mad is Sane.



0 Comments

    AuthorBot

    Dom Shaw is the author of 'Eric is Awake' and also a fleshy tube of chemicals working as a writer, scriptwriter and filmmaker in the UK. Was a boy, now a man. He lives.  

    Archives

    January 2024
    May 2020
    March 2019
    August 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013

    Categories

    All
    All The Years Of Trying
    Ana Mendieta Carl Andre Cliched Conversations Tate Gallery Quentin Crisp Modern Art Rome Stephen Geller
    Anti-apartheid Chris De Broglio Portman Court Hotel Breyten Breytenbach South Africa Sport Peter Hain Arthur Ashe Muhammad Ali
    Bradley Manning Hacktivists Ancient Rome Standing On Your Head Monetise
    Cabal
    Celebrities St James's Park Angelina Jolie Brad Pitt Heron Pelicans Russell Crowe Squirrels Entertainment Industry Paparazzi
    Chemical Weapons Convention Syria Obama John Kerry Putin Bismarck Realpolitik Germany Prussia Gas Russia Us
    CIA
    Comey
    Coronavirus
    Deep State
    Depression
    Drugs Legalisation Herion Nhs Mike Barton Durham Police Chief Transform Drug Policy Foundation
    FBI
    General Alexander James Clapper Nsa Gchq Mi5 Samuel Johnson Patriotism Gchq Math Orwellian Arithmetic Patriot Act Usa Uk Special Relationship
    George Orwell Isle Of Jura Barnhill 1984 Eric Blair Awake
    Harold Wilson
    Insurrection
    Iran Nowruz Huac Zero Mostel Mi5 Gchq
    Juvenal Fourth Estate David Miranda Glenn Greenwald Yochai Benkler Brendan O'neill Guardian Newspaper Hacking Scandal Leveson Fleet Street
    Lockdown
    MI5
    Miranda Censorship Journalism Snowden Milton Areopagitica Orwell Prention Of Literature Soviet Putin Bulgakov
    Mitt Romney Bain Capital Seamus Dog
    Nelson Mandela ANC Ruth First Church Street Bombing Ghandi Non-violence Umkhonto We Sizwe
    Nsa Mi5 Snowden Bletchley Park Surveillance Roman Empire Pax Romana
    Olympics Queen Sun City Mandela Apartheid Sports Boycott Stephen Fry Sebastian Coe Joe Ebrahim South Africa Dennis Brutus Tommie Smith John Carlos
    Orwell 1984 Brighton Writers Group Novel Us Tv
    Orwell 1984 Surveillance Nsa
    Panasonic AJ-HPX3700 Gorilla David Attenborough Wildlife Cameraman
    Patrik Fitzgerald Punk Poet Bob Geldof Boomtown Rats Roundhouse London Benjamin Zephaniah Everett True Rough Cut And Ready Dubbed
    Peter Wright
    Porlock Samuel Taylor Coleridge Inspiration Ideas Writers
    Public Sector Nhs Privatise Bbc John Birt Corpritization
    Red Things Rough Cut And Ready Dubbed Art Of The Critic Eric Is Awake Richard Dreyfus Close Encounters
    Retrospective Diagnosis Mentally Ill Lithium Orwell Christopher Hitchens Aspergers Fox Network Socialist
    Russell Brand Revolution Voting Is Dead Democracy Chartists Orwell Yeats Awake
    Russian Revolution Harry Young Lenin Comintern Bukharin Zinoviev Young Communist League Uk Cockney Commissar
    Scriptwriting
    Sedition
    Snowden Privacy Electronic Frontier Foundation Tor Network Reset The Net Julius Caesar Cryptography Encryption Mi5 Nsa Gchq Hello Kitty Google Metadata Intrusion
    Thoreau Walden Living Off The Grid Society Drop Out Self-sufficiency Nuisance Abatement Survivalists Living Off The Land
    Tony Blair David Cameron Syria War History Falklands Bosnia
    Tracey Emin Ivan Massow Conceptual Art Ica Critics Comedy Film
    Trump
    Writing

    RSS Feed